Audio Transcript

If we transcribed our prayers from the last year and shared them with each other, what would be obvious? Would it show lofty prayers for the nations? Would we be found praying most often that God’s name be hallowed on earth? Or would we see in those transcripts a lot of self-centered prayers that constantly revolve around our daily needs? And if that was what we found, would that really be a problem? As we will read in our Bible reading, 1 John 5 tells us that if we ask for anything according to God’s will, he will hear us. Today on Ask Pastor John: Are my prayers too selfish?

It’s the question on the mind of Bridget. She’s a college student at UMass Amherst. “Pastor John, hello, and thank you for the Ask Pastor John podcast. I’ve been thinking a lot about this question of prayer. In 1 John 5:14–15,” in our reading tomorrow, “we receive the great promise that if we ask for anything according to God’s will, he hears and answers us. First Peter 5:7 welcomes us to cast all our cares on him. But then James 4:3 warns us that prayers driven by selfish motives won’t be answered.

“I’m trying to fit these texts together in practice. We are encouraged to bring all our cares to God, so I get confused about how much we need to pre-align them with his will before we even speak them. Are we truly free to pray for anything, or are we only supposed to pray for certain cares? What I’m really trying to figure out is this: before I start praying for something specific I really want, how can I know if my desire is in line with God’s will or if the desire is selfish?”

The Danger of Selfish Prayer

Maybe digging into the context of James 4:3, which Bridget refers to, might shed light on how to know if our motivations are pleasing to God when we come to him in prayer. It’s surprising, even shocking imagery that we find here in James 4:1–5.

Listen: “You do not have, because you do not ask. You ask and do not receive, because you ask wrongly.” Now, that’s the question: What’s “wrongly”? What is it to pray badly? “To spend it on your passions. You [adulteresses]!” Now, the translation “adulteresses” is important. It is plain, straightforward, and feminine (moichalides). To translate it “adulterous people” doesn’t help us. It is feminine, and it is “adulteresses,” and the image being created is crucial, and you can’t see it without the word adulteresses: “You adulteresses.”

There are people in this church who are acting like adulteresses. They are acting like they belong to God as their husband while they’re acting like an unfaithful wife. “Do you not know that friendship with the world is enmity with God?” That is, a wife who goes after other lovers (namely, the world) is going to make her husband angry — justifiably jealous (namely, God). “Therefore whoever wishes to be a friend of the world,” the paramour down the hall, “makes himself an enemy of God,” the jilted husband. “Or do you suppose it is to no purpose that the Scripture says, ‘He yearns jealously over the spirit that he has made to dwell in us’?” That’s what a good husband does. A good husband feels indignant and has a deep sense of, “You’re mine. You shouldn’t give yourself to another man.”

“Selfishness is when you want something and you’re going to seek it whether it dishonors God or not.”

So, we’re talking about prayer. We’re talking about prayer in this paragraph. And James is saying there is a kind of prayer that treats God like a cuckold. It refers to a husband whose wife is cheating on him. That’s a cuckold. Christians are making God into a cuckold. How? When it says they are praying just to spend it on their passions. The picture is of an unfaithful wife who asked her husband for $50 so she can go down the hall and pay another man to have sex with her. That’s the picture. She’s using prayer to cheat on her husband, God.

What Is a Selfish Prayer?

How does that help us answer the question of how to sort out whether we are praying in accord with God’s will or being selfish?

Don’t make the word selfish include everything you want. That’s not what selfish means. You wouldn’t pray at all if you didn’t want anything. To want something, to desire something, is not necessarily selfish. Otherwise, breathing would be selfish, eating would be selfish, and sleeping would be selfish. The word selfish doesn’t simply mean having desires and wanting them satisfied.

Selfishness is when you want something and you’re going to seek it whether it hurts others or not, or whether it dishonors God or not. You’re going to elevate your private desires above the good of others and above the glory of God. That’s what selfish is. And that’s what James means when he says, “You ask wrongly, to spend it on your passions” (James 4:3).

Praying Well

So now we’ve got at least three marks of good prayers. One is that we want something. Otherwise, we wouldn’t be asking.

Second, we want God to be glorified by the answer. When we ask our husband for something, we want him to be honored by the way we spend it and use it. That’s what a good wife does. That’s even more important than whether we get the answer: that he be honored by what he gave us.

And third, we want the answer to be good for people, not just good for ourselves. That’s the kind of husband we have. He loves it when the wife is generous to others.

When Jesus taught us to pray the first three petitions of the Lord’s Prayer (Matthew 6:9–10), he was showing us these three priorities:

  1. Cause your name to be hallowed.
  2. Cause your kingdom to come.
  3. Cause your will to be done.

These are petitions, requests, not acclamations. They express our desires. We want them to happen. That’s why we’re praying. They are our desires. Second, besides being our desires, they are supremely for the glory of God. That’s what hallowing God’s name means. Our first and ultimate request is that God would make his name revered, loved, treasured, trusted, and hallowed. We want the name of God to be great in the world, great in our lives, great in our families, and great in our church. We want him to be the supreme value.

“James is saying there is a kind of prayer that treats God like a cuckold.”

And then third, when his saving reign comes into a person’s life (“Your kingdom come”) and his will is done here on earth the way the angels do it in heaven (humbly, willingly, joyfully), then we know this is good for people. When people come under the saving reign of God, they are saved. And when they do his will from their hearts, this is a great blessing for people and for the church and for the mission of God in the world.

This is the opposite of James 4:3: “You ask and do not receive, because you ask wrongly, to spend it on your passions.” No, we’re not aiming to spend it on our passions. We’re aiming to have our holy desires satisfied in the good that we are asking for. And we measure its good not only by meeting some legitimate desire that we have but by whether it hallows God’s name and blesses other people. That’s how we measure the quality of our requests to God.

Prayer’s Helper

Now, lest I leave the impression it’s easy to always discern what is for the glory of God, what is for the good of others, and what is for the good of ourselves, I really should add Romans 8:26: “The Spirit helps us in our weakness. For we do not know [how to pray] as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words.” That verse comes right after Paul says we groan in our suffering, mortal bodies (Romans 8:23). So, I think Paul is saying, “We don’t always know what to pray for — for the body to be healed or for the body to be patient as we wait for the final day: resurrection healing.”

So, Bridget and the rest of us should take heart that even the greatest apostle, I think, Paul, was regularly unsure what to pray for. But that doesn’t leave us in confusion. We know that it’s good to ask for our heart’s desires and that it’s good to seek those desires in longing for the glory of God and for the good of others. And when we are uncertain, Paul says, “Don’t worry. The Spirit of God himself will groan within you, and God will know your heart.”