Audio Transcript

Welcome back to the podcast on this Thanksgiving week. Yesterday, we read about Jesus washing the feet of his disciples in John 13. Jesus worked his basin of water from disciple to disciple on the floor. When he reached Peter, Peter instinctively pulled his feet back and said, “You shall never wash my feet.” Then “Jesus answered him, ‘If I do not wash you, you have no share with me.’ Simon Peter said to him, ‘Lord, not my feet only but also my hands and my head!’” Dump the basin on my head. Give me a shower! And then “Jesus said to him, ‘The one who has bathed does not need to wash, except for his feet, but is completely clean. And you are clean’” (John 13:8–10). Peter is clean. He was chosen, and he was redeemed. Christ’s future work has already applied to him. Now he only needs his feet washed.

Confessing sin is a part of daily cleansing (1 John 1:9), and that practice is never inconsistent with being “completely clean.” Peter is a living metaphor for justification and sanctification. And it tells me we can miss what Christ has done for us because we have dirt on our feet. We fixate on washing off the dust every day. We obsess over daily sanctification and forget that Christ washed us clean. Today on Ask Pastor John: how to beat scrupulosity.

Today’s question is from a middle-aged man named Dave. “Pastor John, thank you for taking my question. I have struggled for many years with scrupulosity. That’s the word I learned last week while watching YouTube videos. When I looked up that word, scrupulosity, I wept for joy. My obsessive fears have destroyed my peace for many years. And I think I have discovered the root of most of my spiritual challenges and struggle with anxiety. So, now I want to ask you, Pastor John, what advice would you give to a man who has for years been paralyzed by scrupulosity?”

There is a similarity between ordinary spiritual attacks that every believer endures, on the one hand, and more sustained obsessions that some believers endure, on the other hand. There’s a similarity. There’s an overlap. In other words, I don’t think we should overstate or understate the peculiar seriousness of what it is to deal with scrupulosity, or what is sometimes called obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

Let me try to illustrate what I mean by the overlap between (1) the normal threat of a thought or an image or a behavior becoming an obsession that all of us experience and (2) the more persistent thoughts or images or behaviors that keep returning and returning, and won’t let a person have any rest, like a tick that bites you on the leg and sinks into your skin, and you try to pull it off, but it just grabs on deeper and harder.

All of us deal with this danger. I’ve dealt with it personally and written about it, mostly in relation to sexual threats. For example, you inadvertently see some sexually riveting situation — say, a couple having sex on the ground behind your garage. Immediately, that image lodges itself in your consciousness with tremendous force. It threatens to take over. It wants to stay there and be developed in living color by your imagination. You can adapt this situation, this sexual temptation, to whatever your temptation is, whatever the threat of repetition is. You know the kind of thing I’m talking about. What do you do?

Fight with ANTHEM

Here’s my strategy. I’ll just sum it up quickly and then show how it might apply to this issue of scrupulosity. ANTHEM is my technique for handling a situation of threatening preoccupation with thoughts that ought not to be in my head.

A: Avoid what triggers the thought or the image. If it’s inadvertent, don’t look back. If you can avoid the trigger in the first place, avoid it.

N: Say no out loud to Satan, to your own mind. No — a strong, decisive no. “You will not have dominion over me (Romans 6:14)!” No to that thought, image, or memory.

T: Turn your mind to another compelling reality. It might be the bloody body of Jesus hanging on the cross to make you pure. It might be the preciousness of your spouse, whom you don’t want to in any way compromise.

H: Hold that image in your mind and continue to hold it. Hold it as long as you have to. Here’s where the battle is lost for many people. They just give up. They just give up and let themselves return to the clamoring image or the clamoring thought or the clamoring behavior.

E: Enjoy. Don’t let yourself think that all the pleasure lies back there with that sexually charged image. There is more pleasure at God’s right hand than anywhere else in the universe (Psalm 16:11). Like we were just talking about, Tony, one day — one day! — “in your courts is better than a thousand elsewhere,” even in what you think is going to give you pleasure (Psalm 84:10). Preach that. Taste that. Cultivate that.

M: Move. Move on in your mind to what God has given you to do. Sweep the room, do the laundry, cut the grass, write the report — move on.

So, that’s ANTHEM. Now, I think that little description of spiritual warfare that applies to every single Christian also applies to those who deal with more serious cases of scrupulosity or obsession. There’s no clear dividing line between normal spiritual warfare and extraordinary cases of scrupulosity. So, let me go a little further and underline a couple of things from ANTHEM and a couple of things that are omitted from ANTHEM that need attention.

Resist with Prayer

We all know from experience, don’t we, that a frontal attack on intrusive thoughts doesn’t work. For example, if you keep thinking there are deadly germs on absolutely everything you touch, it won’t work to continually say to yourself, Stop thinking about deadly germs. Stop thinking about deadly germs. That kind of frontal attack just keeps the thought in front of your mind. We all know this. It’s just obvious from experience. A frontal attack like that doesn’t work by itself. If an obsessive thought is to be pushed out of the mind, it must be pushed out by replacing it with something else. This is what I meant by the H — hold. Hold onto that alternative reality that you’ve put there in your mind.

“God is in the business of pulling our hearts away from sinful obsessions.”

And the reason I want to underline this is because the Bible so clearly says that God has given us the mental capacity to direct what the mind is set on. We sometimes feel like we’re just victims. We’re not just victims. Colossians 3:2 says, “Set your minds on things that are above, not on things that are on earth.” First Chronicles 22:19: “Set your mind and heart to seek the LORD.” Romans 8:5: “Set [your mind] on the things of the Spirit.”

The Bible assumes that the mind has an amazing capacity to direct itself away from some thoughts toward other thoughts. And we should just go for that. We should use that capacity.

One of the most glaring omissions, however, of my ANTHEM strategy (and I don’t know how to spell ANTHEM any other way) is that it doesn’t explicitly mention prayer. Oh, how crucial is prayer. Covering every step — maybe that’s the way to think about it; it’s over all the letters — covering every step of ANTHEM should be the cry, “Help me. Deliver me. Direct my mind.”

And we have every reason to think, to believe God has designed prayer for this very deliverance, because David says in Psalm 119:36, “Incline my heart to your testimonies, [O God].” God is in the business of pulling our hearts away from sinful obsessions. That’s what incline means. “Incline the heart. Pull my heart away from these obsessions.” So, cover the entire process of active resistance with prayer.

Make the Promises Personal

Another glorious reality that’s not mentioned explicitly in ANTHEM is to make Christ’s atonement personal. Say with the apostle Paul, “[He] loved me and gave himself for me” (Galatians 2:20). Don’t just speak of the precious sacrifice of Christ for sinners in some general way. Make it, speak it, feel it, sing it personally. “He loved me. He loved me and gave himself for me.” And, of course, that implies he’s going to help you. He is. He has already decisively forgiven you, already decisively justified you, adopted you. These battles that you’re fighting, that we’re fighting, are cleanup operations, skirmishes. He has won the day.

And finally, I would suggest that you bring specific biblical promises to bear on specific intrusive thoughts that are making you scrupulous about them. Suppose the intrusive thought is I’ve not done enough. I’ve not done enough. I’ve not done enough to prove that I’m born again. I’ve not done enough to prove that I’m united to Christ. I’ve tried to witness more. I’ve tried to pray more. I’ve tried to give more. I’ve tried to read my Bible more. I’ve tried to serve the poor more. And still the thoughts come. It’s not enough. It’s not enough.

So, take hold of a specific Bible promise with regard to that particular intrusive lie. For example, Hebrews 9:14: “How much more will the blood of Christ . . . purify our conscience from dead works to serve the living God.” Those works that keep threatening your soul, saying, “You’ve not done enough. You’ve not done enough” — they are deadly. They are deadly. They will kill you. And Jesus shed his blood specifically to purify your heart from those dead works.

Dave, thank you for the question. I know that I’ve only scratched the surface. And so, my concluding advice is to seek out wise, solid, spiritual, even medical counsel (if you think it’s wise) from those you know best. We need each other in these things. We need the church.