Audio Transcript

“Jesus wept” (John 11:35). It’s the shortest verse in the Bible. We read it together in the Navigators Bible Reading Plan yesterday. But it’s so brief we can pass it too quickly. Maybe we pass over it because we think we know what it means. Jesus’s friend Lazarus died. Jesus wept because his friend was gone. But what if we got that wrong? Or, what if we mistakenly thought his emotions were simple when they were complex? What if Jesus wept not simply in the loss of death but from a frustration with the living? Today on Ask Pastor John: what we get wrong about the tears of Jesus.

Henry, a listener, writes in with a timely question on John 11:35. “Pastor John, thank you for taking my question today. I’d like to ask you about John 11:35. Why do you think Jesus wept at the tomb of Lazarus? One way to read this account is that he’s simply sharing in Mary and Martha’s sorrows over his death. But I wonder if something deeper is going on here. Jesus already planned to raise Lazarus, and he even told his disciples he was going to do it in John 11:11–15.

“So, my questions are these two: First, why does Jesus ask, ‘Where have you laid him?’ Was he simply asking to be taken to the tomb? When they answer, ‘Lord, come and see,’ it’s almost like they still don’t appreciate who he is as the Messiah. And that is my second question: This whole event leaves me wondering if this weeping is more like Jesus’s weeping over Jerusalem in Luke 19:41 — weeping because he is heartbroken over the city’s unbelief. Is it a stretch to connect these two moments? Is Jesus grieving the dead Lazarus? Or is he grieving the unbelief of the living?”

Jesus’s Mingled Emotions

I doubt that any of Jesus’s emotions were simple. I think they were always complex. We finite creatures have emotions that respond to one or two, maybe three, happy or painful aspects of a situation. So, we may feel sorrow and joy mingled because, say, a very old saint has just gone to be with the Lord, and we will miss him, and yet we’re so happy for him. But Jesus could see every angle, every imaginable aspect of a situation, some of which called for very different emotions. So, I doubt that he ever had a simple emotion.

For example, in Mark 3:1–5, there’s this man with a withered hand in the synagogue, and the people are watching to see if Jesus would heal him so that they could accuse Jesus. Can you imagine? They don’t give a hoot about this man’s pain. All they want is to accuse Jesus if he heals him. And in verse 5, it says, “He looked around at them with anger, grieved at their hardness of heart.” And that’s what I mean by complex emotions: anger and grief perfectly mingled in the sinless heart of Jesus.

Another example would be that he looked on unbelieving Jerusalem and wept: “Would that you, even you, had known on this day the things that make for peace! But now they are hidden from your eyes” (Luke 19:42). But in Luke 10:21, it says Jesus “rejoiced in the Holy Spirit and said, ‘I thank you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, that you have hidden these things from the wise and understanding and revealed them to little children; yes, Father, for such was your gracious will.’” He could weep and rejoice over the wise and bitter providence of God.

So, we come to John 11 and the death of Lazarus. And I think Henry, who’s sending us this question, is right when he says Jesus’s tears in John 11 aren’t just about sharing our human grief — that maybe he is genuinely mourning their spiritual blindness. Yes, and I’m going to say not just mourning — he’s indignant.

Divine Love and Wisdom

The story begins in John 11:1–6 with Mary and Martha sending words to Jesus that their brother Lazarus is very sick. Jesus waits two more days before going and intentionally lets Lazarus die. He says in John 11:14–15, “Lazarus has died, and for your sake I am glad that I was not there, so that you may believe.” That’s an amazing statement: “I let him die for the sake of your faith.”

“They needed to see the glory of Jesus more than they needed the life of their brother.”

Why didn’t he go heal him? Verses 5 and 6 take the answer even further and explain why: “Jesus loved Martha and her sister [Mary] and Lazarus. So [that’s the key word] when he heard that Lazarus was ill, he stayed two days longer in the place where he was.” That’s incredible. He let Lazarus die because he loved them. There was something that they needed more than their brother. What? John 11:4: “This illness does not lead to death. It is for the glory of God, so that the Son of God may be glorified through it.” They needed to see the glory of Jesus more than they needed the life of their brother.

This is what is strange and wonderful about the story. The love of Jesus prioritizes the revelation of his glory above the life of a saint. It gives us what we really need most. That’s what love does: It gives us what we need most, even if we don’t know we need it most. And what we need most is not the life of our loved ones. It’s to see and know and treasure and to be with Jesus. That’s the point of the story.

Deeply Moved and Troubled

Now, how does it unfold? Badly. It unfolds painfully, not primarily because Lazarus has died but because three times the love of Jesus is questioned. This is what is missed so often as people sentimentalize this story. In the most painful part of the story, Martha questions, Mary questions, and the mourners question. And this threefold doubting of Jesus’s love and wisdom grieves him. Indeed, it shakes him deeply. It makes him indignant.

First, Martha, in John 11:21: “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.” That was a very thinly veiled questioning of Jesus’s motives. “Why weren’t you here?” Second, Mary, in John 11:32: “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.” Why weren’t you here? Third, the mourners in John 11:37: “Could not he who opened the eyes of the blind man also have kept this man from dying?”

It seems to me that most interpreters, most preachers — I don’t think I’ve ever heard an exception — are so quick to think this text is about how Jesus sympathized with mourners that they interpret the entire story in terms of the humanity of Jesus rising up with compassion for the hurting and with indignation at the reality of death. That’s the way it’s preached almost all the time. I don’t think that’s the point of the story. I think the point of the story is this: How does Jesus plan to reveal his glory, and how does he respond to those who are suspicious because they don’t like the way he’s doing it?

“That’s what love does: It gives us what we need most, even if we don’t know we need it most.”

There are two words at the end of John 11:33 that describe Jesus’s response. So, first, Martha had questioned his delay. And now, in verse 32, Mary questions his delay. And his response is he was “deeply moved” (enebrimēsato) — a very unusual, rare Greek word. “He was deeply moved in his spirit and greatly troubled” (John 11:33). Now, that first word, “deeply moved,” is used again in verse 38. We’ll see it in just a minute. And then, three times outside the Gospel, it never, never is a word of compassion but a word of rebuke or warning. Jesus is indignant.

And the other word, “greatly troubled” (tarassesthō), signifies being shaken, agitated. It’s the word Jesus used in John 14:1: “Let not your hearts be troubled.” It’s not a positive emotion. Jesus was shaken, and he was upset and disturbed.

Grief over Doubt, Not Death

And it’s amazing how many interpreters think that these strong words referred to Jesus’s indignation at the reality of death. How many sermons have I heard about that? But Jesus had planned this death. He planned it. He knew exactly what he was doing when he waited two more days to let Lazarus die so that he could reveal his glory by raising him from the dead. I don’t think Jesus’s indignation is directed toward the death of Lazarus.

In fact (and this is what settles it for me), in verse 38, where Jesus uses this strong word one more time, the same word of indignation, John, who’s writing this story, makes it explicit what he is reacting to. And he does so with the word therefore. In verse 37, for the third time, Jesus is doubted: “Could not he who opened the eyes of the blind also have kept this man from dying?” And then John says, “[Therefore],” because of that questioning, “Jesus, deeply moved [disturbed, indignant] again, came to the tomb” (John 11:38).

So, I think Henry is right. This is a story about the Christ-exalting, glory-revealing love of Jesus being questioned, and his grief and indignation over this doubt — yes, no doubt mingled with the other emotions of the hour. This is not a man with simple emotions, and we do well not to sentimentalize the story.