Are Wedding Rings a Waste of Money?
Are Weddings Rings a Waste of Money? (Episode 364)
The following is a transcript of the audio.
This is the season of weddings and many wedding related questions have come into the mailbag. Two interesting ones on wedding rings are related. Chris writes in to ask: “As I consider engagement, I have trouble giving in to the idea of spending a large sum of money on a ring. I have a great desire to do so for my current girlfriend, but a diamond holds no eternal value, and better things could be done with $3,000. Is a fancy engagement ring really necessary or is this just something society tells us we need?” And Aaron asks: “Pastor John, what are your thoughts on diamond rings for engagements? Is it a poor use of resources to buy even a modest diamond ring?” So, Pastor John, maybe I can simplify this to two questions about Christian engagement and wedding rings: (1) Are rings optional or essential? (2) Are diamonds optional or essential?
Ok. Yeah. Those last two questions are easy.
And the bigger picture may not be so easy. Wedding rings and engagement diamonds are not essential. They are not essential for engagement. They are not essential for marriage. They are not essential for love. That is easy. Both diamonds and engagements and rings for marriage are culturally defined, not biblically mandated. Ok, we could just stop right there. I suppose that is not what Chris wants. I am sure he wants me to say more than that and I have lots more to say than that. So here it goes. Let me try to say something in addition that might put it in a bigger biblical context.
Yes you could save money. You could. And if you built your houses without windows you would save money, too. And yards would be more economical if you didn’t plant any flowers and just had grass or maybe even better just dirt and wedding anniversaries and birthdays and Christmas would be cheaper if you dispensed with gift sharing. All of these would result in more money going to the poor, to missions if you were disciplined enough to calculate it that way. So no rings, no diamonds would clearly be cheaper and the money would go to, perhaps, more compassionate uses. True.
So the question is: Are wedding rings and engagement rings warranted expenses? Are they justifiable in the light of biblical truth?
So let me start with wedding rings. I think culturally it is wise and good for a husband and a wife to wear a wedding ring for two reasons. Number one it sends a signal to everyone that you relate to that you are married and therefore committed to a lover and not available for anyone else. It is a symbol in our culture. I am taken. I am not available. Don’t deal with me as a candidate for sex and don’t deal with me as a candidate for marriage. My ring is a true statement that helps me navigate the cultural waters in wise and faithful ways.
Second reason I think it is wise. A wedding ring is a great reminder to us that we are married and that it is till death do us part. It represents a sacred set of vows that we made which should govern every day of our married lives. I never take my wedding ring off ever unless some doctor makes it do it because I have got to have prostate cancer. In 45 years, all right, 45 years my wedding ring has been off my finger less than 24 hours, I think. Two surgeries and I fought them, but they won. They wouldn’t let me go into surgery with my ring on though I got it back on as soon as I came out. Why? I am Noel Piper’s husband and I want to be known that way. That is what that ring signifies to everybody and it signifies to me: I love this woman. I am committed to her till I die. And I made promises to her I am going to do my dead best to keep. So I love this symbol and I believe in it.
So if there are good reasons to wear this ring, then there are probably good reasons to purchase it. And I will come back to the cost in just a minute. So that was my little case for: Yeah, good idea. Go ahead, have wedding rings.
Now what about engagement? What about the diamond? Betrothal has its roots in the Bible. Mary and Joseph were betrothed. There is things about betrothal in the Bible, but no biblical mandate for any period of betrothal in the Bible and no biblical mandate for anything that requires engagement let alone any symbol of engagement. But, again, I would say it seems wise. This tradition seems wise. It is a season when neither the man nor the woman relates to other men and women in ways that could be construed as romantic or tending toward that kind of relationship. It is a focused season of upper level commitment that hasn’t reached the commitment of the vows of marriage yet. And it seems to me that that kind of staged or staggered or leveled relationship or commitment while you focus on knowing one another and discerning each other’s natures is a good and wise thing.
The reason a ring is generally given only to the woman is that culturally it has generally been viewed as fitting that men, not women, take the initiative in pursuing a relationship. That means that when a man sees an engagement ring on a woman’s finger he knows, this woman is betrothed. It is a level of commitment, short of marriage, but deeply significant. And, of course, it always signifies from the man: I love you, and I want you to be my wife. And that is the direction we are moving unless something really surprising happens. So if that expression of love and that season of engagement with visibility to others is wise, then it seems to me like some kind of investment is also wise.
Now last few comments on the cost. I love it when I hear of couples that are so in tune with each other in matters of lifestyle that they happily agree that the symbols of their love will not need to be exorbitantly expensive. I have known couples who decide on another kind of beautiful stone besides a diamond, for example, a birth stone. It not only didn’t break the bank, it was beautifully distinct and fit her personality perfectly. But if you are going to go against the cultural current like that, it is really, really important, crucial that you know each other deeply. How valuable is this symbol to her really? Is she just saying: Oh, it doesn’t matter, because she wants to please you and deep down she would be profoundly disappointed. No one can put a dollar amount on a woman or a man or on the value of engagement or on the value of marriage. And so no one can put a value on these symbols. No amount of money would tell the truth about the value of the person. So don’t try to attach the value of the person with the value of the ring. It won’t work.
Can I just throw in a pet peeve here, Tony? I want to throw in my pet peeve about $10,000–20,000 wedding receptions. I think this is a deplorable tradition. So here I go absolutizing, right? No, no. I am not absolutizing. I am just giving my judgment about a trend that I think has gotten way out of hand. I would love to see pastors and parents and young people all agree that the joy after a wedding does not need tens of thousands of dollars of the finest hotel, finest retreat center, finest band, finest cuisine. It is crazy the money that is being sunk into these things. I think I personally think this couple... I mean, get this clear. This couple wants to get on the road. And cake and nuts will be remembered as happily as caviar. So all that... now I have got my rant over. All that to say in all this—rings, wedding rings, engagement rings, receptions—keep it simple. Keep it beautiful. And amp up the ways of showing love that cost little and mean much.
Yeah, that was a rant — but it was a happy rant. We’ll be back tomorrow to talk about weddings again, specifically would you, Pastor John, marry a couple that was living together? If you want to ask Pastor John wedding question — or any question — please email it in to us at AskPastorJohn@desiringGod.org. And please check out desiringGod.org to find thousands of books, sermons, articles, and blog posts from John Piper, always free of charge to you. I’m your host Tony Reinke, see you tomorrow.
©2014 Desiring God Foundation. Used by Permission.
Permissions: You are permitted and encouraged to reproduce and distribute this material in its entirety or in unaltered excerpts, as long as you do not charge a fee. For Internet posting, please use only unaltered excerpts (not the content in its entirety) and provide a hyperlink to this page. Any exceptions to the above must be approved by Desiring God.
Please include the following statement on any distributed copy: By John Piper. ©2014 Desiring God Foundation. Website: desiringGod.org