Can’t You Just Do Something New?
Assumptions of Unhealthy Churches
How often does church-leadership content online reveal a lightly veiled obsession with new? The experts today might not come out and say it, but the assumption often seems to be: Surely after two thousand years and all of our light-year advances in technology, the church needs a serious upgrade. Capturing this sentiment, one article insists, “Church leaders face two options. Either battle the marketplace currents and strive to convince enough people to pay for sermon-centric Sunday gatherings, or rethink that model to better fit the realities of making disciples in the twenty-first century.”
Someone recently shared a clip with me that illustrates one such updated model. The video features a popular preacher who begins his Sunday sermon by driving a Rolls-Royce onto a stage. Twenty-two screens surround him, and hundreds of light bulbs hang overhead. The “preacher” steps out of the half-a-million-dollar car and takes critics like me head-on:
There are some of you who are saying, “Oh man, I can’t believe you drove a Rolls-Royce into church. Man, that’s gimmicky.” No, it’s not; it’s godly. “Oh, that’s trite. That’s flippant.” No, it’s from Christ’s playbook. If you ever go to church and you find yourself bored, blame the communicator, the pastor. Don’t blame God. Yeah, for some reason we go to church and expect boredom. Just the opposite should be true. We are — and this is going to mess you up — we are in the entertainment business.
I agree that no one should be bored in church — and I certainly agree that God is not to blame for any boredom in the pews. This preacher’s gimmick implies, however, that the same old formula for church — prayer, singing, fellowship, preaching — can’t possibly keep the attention of modern people like you. Mere sermons won’t cut it. God needs us to spice things up.
God is not surprised by our state-of-the-art technology or shriveling attention spans, and he has told us, from the beginning, what captures souls when we gather for worship. He’s told us how to do church, and his counsel hasn’t expired.
A Church Anyone Would Want
Do you want to hear about a church that was emphatically not bored?
They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers. And awe came upon every soul, and many wonders and signs were being done through the apostles. And all who believed were together and had all things in common. And they were selling their possessions and belongings and distributing the proceeds to all, as any had need. And day by day, attending the temple together and breaking bread in their homes, they received their food with glad and generous hearts, praising God and having favor with all the people. And the Lord added to their number day by day those who were being saved. (Acts 2:42–47)
Don’t you want to be a part of a church like that? Don’t you want your local church to taste the camaraderie, sacrifice, growth, and joy these people experienced when they gathered? The God-authored recipe is remarkably simple and durable: “They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers.” What did this church do when it grew so wildly and unexpectedly?
- They gathered.
- They ate.
- They gave.
- They prayed.
- They preached.
And because they devoted themselves to God’s inspired Sunday-service plan, they rejoiced and their numbers multiplied. It’s dumbfounding that we see this kind of church thrive for literally millennia and still conclude it’s time to shake things up. “Sunday sermons got us this far,” we say, “but we’ll take it from here.”
What if God knew everything we know — artificial intelligence, fiber-optic internet, driverless cars, those new robot vacuums that can clean stairs — and deliberately told churches to pray, sing, eat, drink, and preach the word anyway?
Preaching to Itching Ears
God knew exactly what changes and pressures our churches would face in the twenty-first century, and so he warned us to aggressively resist the relentless pull of new:
Preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching. For the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions, and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths. (2 Timothy 4:2–4)
The time is now here when “people will not endure sound teaching,” but will search for something else to satisfy them. They’re terribly and persistently bored with what God has to say in Scripture, and so they need someone to put on a show to make the Bible a little more palatable. They’re passionate about cars, so give them a fancy car. They’re passionate about movies, so show them a clip. They need viral props — itch. They need hip music — itch. They need high fashion — itch. Anything to make them forget they have to listen to someone talk about the Bible again.
“We don’t need church to be new. We need churches that hear from God.”
Watching the preacher step out of the Rolls and talk about his “entertainment business” made me think of parents shoving a pill into a dessert so their kids might swallow it without noticing. Is that really how we think about the word of God?
This God invented light; built planets; carved oceans; gave the lion its mane, the shark its teeth, and the beaver its tail; sent his Son; is redeeming those from every tribe, tongue, people, and nation; and will judge every soul on earth — and he wrote a book. Why wouldn’t we run to put the preached word at the heart of our every gathering? Oh, that the ears of our hearts would be like Mary, “who sat at the Lord’s feet and listened to his teaching” (Luke 10:39). Oh, for more churches to choose the good portion (Luke 10:42).
The New Church We Need
I pity the preacher who thinks he needs to drive a Rolls-Royce into his pulpit to entice people to pay attention to God. The irony — and tragedy — is that he’s actually teaching his people to be bored with God. He thinks he’s winning them to the Bible, but he’s actually catechizing his people to despise the Bible. He’s training ears to itch.
A far better approach, Mark Dever says, is not to entertain with gimmicks but to enthrall with the gospel:
We need a new model for the church. Actually, the model we need is an old one. . . . Simply put, we need churches that are self-consciously distinct from the culture. We need churches in which the key indicator of success is not evident results but persevering biblical faithfulness. We need churches that help us to recover those aspects of Christianity that are distinct from the world, and that unite us. (Nine Marks of a Healthy Church, 34–35)
We don’t need church to be new. We need churches that hear from God. We need, as much as ever, churches who devote “themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers.” We need churches who eagerly receive the word, live the word, and preach the word — who never apologize for anything they find in Scripture and who feel no need to compensate for its “weaknesses.” Churches like these will be gloriously old and glad as they worship the one who is making all things new.